Toyota 4Runner Years To Avoid And Best Years To Buy [2025]

The Toyota 4Runner is an off-road capable SUV designed for adventure. However, this doesn’t protect it from occasional issues such as rust buildup and costly repairs.

Understanding which years to avoid can help make smarter used-car purchases. Therefore, in this blog post we’ll explore Toyota 4Runner years to avoid, the most reliable and best Toyota 4Runner years, and some interesting tips to buy a used Toyota 4Runner.

Toyota 4Runner Years To Avoid: Comprehensive Overview

A small research project by yourself before making any big decision ensures that you’re investing in the right place, and for a happy vehicle purchase, this article can help you a lot. However, here are the Toyota 4Runner years to avoid to help save you from potential headaches down the road.

1988-1989 Toyota 4Runner (First-Generation)

Toyota introduced their original 4Runner model in 1984 as an off-roading SUV with a simple design. Unfortunately, however, these early 4Runners experienced some reliability issues.

These vehicles often suffered from issues related to rust and head gasket failure that could potentially be fixed, yet still impact the way in which the vehicle functions. Furthermore, such cars often had sagging rear suspensions which severely limited how well it performed its function.

Regardless, when purchasing a used Toyota 4Runner it is wise to avoid 1988-1989 first-generation models equipped with the 3.0-liter engine and 1990-1995 second-generation models due to excessive rust issues – although rust may no longer be prevalent, so any second generation cars should also be avoided as far as possible.

With proper research you should find a suitable used 4Runner. Please always conduct an extensive inspection prior to making your purchase and obtain a vehicle history report as well as consulting a professional mechanic for any necessary maintenance services before committing.

1990-1995 Toyota 4Runner (Second-Generation)

Reliability is of utmost importance when shopping for used SUVs, as it will dictate both its cost and mileage capabilities. When purchasing a Toyota 4Runner, make sure you select one of its more reliable years to maximize value and road time.

Toyota 4Runner models from its second generation offer excellent roadgoing SUV and off-road capabilities, and have few issues and provide improved fuel economy. In addition, these cars feature side impact beams to protect front occupants should a collision occur.

The original 4Runner is also an excellent option; however, those with V6 engines should avoid model years from 1990-1995 due to head gasket leaks that may lead to overheating and engine damage as well as quickly rusting vehicles.

2001-2002 Toyota 4Runner (Third-Generation)

The second-generation Toyota 4Runner is notorious for having issues with rust and head gasket failure, both of which can become costly to fix over time. However, 2003-2005 models seem less susceptible to these issues.

Although it faced its fair share of difficulties, this generation still had plenty to offer. Both SR5 and base model 4Runners received new transparent tail lights; Limited models got five-spoke design wheels. A selectable electric rear differential was also introduced during this model year. Other changes included redesigned climate control with 3 knobs and 2 buttons as well as front row side torso airbags as well as tire pressure monitoring systems.

Consider reliability when purchasing a used SUV. Toyota 4Runner models boast some of the highest reliability scores on the market today; however, some might not. Use this guide as a means to avoid making an unwise investment and save both time and money down the line.

Toyota 4Runner Years To Avoid: 2003-2005 Models (Fourth-Generation)

With the rollout of the fifth generation 4Runner, owners are showing great enthusiasm. This SUV has transformed from being an off-road beast into a smooth road going machine while still possessing its rugged capabilities. However, there are certain things buyers should look out for when shopping around for one.

The fourth-generation model year saw some major issues to avoid, such as frame and body rusting that could weaken its framework and lead to costly repair bills. Some of these models also experienced dashboard cracking problems that not only looked unsightly but could interfere with airbag deployment and become safety risks.

A frequent issue with the fourth-generation 4Runner was its sagging suspension, which severely compromised ride quality and handling. There have also been reports of paint peeling affecting future resale value; furthermore, certain models in this generation experienced issues with its rear differential; Toyota eventually fixed these problems by making their fix standard on all models.

The Most Reliable Years Of Toyota 4Runner

Toyota finally found success with the fifth-generation 4Runner SUV, as this generation saw far fewer complaints and issues like rust than before.

However, problems still remained including head gasket failures and automatic transmission problems; these should still be taken into consideration when shopping for used model years.

1986-1987 Toyota 4Runner (First-Generation)

Toyota 4Runner stands out in an SUV market plagued by unreliability, as this veteran light-duty truck has earned itself a place among off-road enthusiasts for its durable frame and rugged suspension system that provide unmatched off-road capability while still cruising smoothly along highways. Furthermore, its second generation features an efficient 2.7L I4 engine capable of 150 horsepower output.

Though the Toyota 4Runner is known for its durability and reliability, it does encounter its share of issues. Rust issues are especially prevalent with 2nd Generation model years (1986-1987). Many also suffer from leaking rear axle seals or radiator failures which result in head gasket failure; cracked dashboards due to sun exposure can also occur with these models.

1990-1993 Toyota 4Runner (Second-Generation)

By 2010, most mid-sized SUVs had moved away from a truck-based design, leaving only Toyota 4Runner as one of few full-frame truck models available to buyers looking for reliability. Even so, its fifth generation models remain packed with modern technologies and off-road features making it an attractive option.

This generation was among the best for owner satisfaction, though certain models experienced some recurring issues. For instance, the 4.0L V6 engine is susceptible to head gasket failures while rear coil spring suspension can experience sagging bottom issues; yet this model year received less than 50 complaints to NHTSA. Also, door lock actuators often malfunction; this issue should be covered under warranty; fortunately this problem was addressed for 2014-2016 models.

1996-1998 Toyota 4Runner (Third-Generation)

Toyota’s 4Runner SUV is an attractive option for anyone searching for an off-roading experience. One of its greatest draws is its reliability; many used options will last a long time with minimal issues. Not all model years offer equal reliability though; certain years may have more issues than others so it’s important to research which year offers optimal reliability before purchasing.

For your convenience, we have outlined the most reliable years of the Toyota 4Runner to assist your decision-making. These models feature less reported issues and less susceptibility to rust. In addition, they come equipped with lots of safety features like adaptive cruise control, lane departure alert and pre-collision warning – plus other advanced safety systems from Toyota like their Safety Sense suite that offers adaptive cruise control, lane-departure alert and pre-collision warning capabilities.

2006-2007 Toyota 4Runner (Fourth-Generation)

The 3rd Generation 4Runner is widely admired for its rugged off-road capability and early refinement, making it a top choice among enthusiasts looking for adventure without spending an arm and a leg.

While this generation began with head gasket issues, its fortunes quickly improved by 2006-2007. This was the best year ever for Toyota 4Runner reliability with only minor NHTSA complaints reported (and none concerning excessive rust like many previous years) being reported.

Furthermore, IIHS certified crash tests gave an acceptable rating and owners appreciated its powerful engine lineup and smooth steering, plus its fold-flat third row design – making this year an excellent opportunity to purchase used 4Runners that could handle off-road adventures or daily commutes alike.

2010-2016 Toyota 4Runner (Fifth-Generation)

Since its production began only recently, the current 5th generation has already earned a name for itself when it comes to off-road capability. Boasting four-wheel drive capabilities and high ground clearance, this model makes an excellent choice for enthusiasts seeking adventure.

However, potential buyers should bear some factors into account before making their decision: brake systems often malfunction unexpectedly while there have been reports of paint/body/rust problems necessitating costly repairs.

Although not without issues, the Toyota 4Runner remains a popular choice among those who desire an authentic truck-based SUV experience. Boasting an efficient engine with great fuel economy and decent towing ability, its solid off-road capabilities and solid off-road handling might satisfy most buyers despite some unsettled rides and poor handling; its infotainment system has recently been enhanced with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration for better connectivity.

Related Article:

Mazda CX-9 Years To Avoid And Best Years: [Extensive Guide]

Tips For Buying A Used Toyota 4Runner

Toyota 4Runner SUVs are popular choices among families seeking used SUVs, thanks to their off-road capabilities and spacious cabin space. When searching for a used 4Runner, be mindful of certain things when shopping so as to get maximum value from your purchase.

Rust Inspection

One of the primary issues plaguing older models is rust. Rust can eat away at floorpans, frame rails and other vital components found beneath a car or truck’s undercarriage, making repairs nearly impossible to make in some areas while other areas remain undamaged by corrosion.

Begin your inspection of this problem using a flashlight and good observation skills; look out for any noticeable differences in sections’ condition where one might expect moderate corrosion such as between sections with no corrosion present versus moderately rusted sections is likely an indicator that repairs were made correctly after bodywork repair was painted over by using appropriate procedures and overpainting techniques.

Check Maintenance Records

It is wise to make sure the owner kept up with regular maintenance of their SUV when buying used. This will allow you to better assess repairs, and give peace of mind knowing it was regularly serviced. Ideally, service records for both engine and transmission should exist with their VIN entering it into the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration database.

If an SUV doesn’t have a VIN number, determining its maintenance history can be challenging. To mitigate this risk, it’s a smart idea to have a pre-purchase inspection performed by an independent mechanic; they will conduct a thorough assessment of cosmetic, mechanical and safety condition that may reveal potential dangers or costly expenses down the line.

Check For Recalls

If a vehicle has ever been recalled, this information will likely be included in its history file. Knowing about recalls for models you’re considering is crucial as recalls may include key safety-related features and equipment that could compromise their integrity and increase risks associated with that model. When shopping used vehicles online you can also search the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration website using the VIN number as a quick way of finding recalls that apply directly.

An inspection can save you time, money and headaches in the future. Furthermore, it can serve as an invaluable bargaining chip when making offers on used cars – it will identify any significant problems while giving a comprehensive view of its overall condition, providing invaluable data that could aid negotiations between buyer and seller.

In conclusion, this post about the best and worst years for Toyota 4Runner could be helpful for a person who is planning to buy a used SUV on a normal budget. So, hopefully all your queries about the Toyota 4Runner years to avoid and which one is the most reliable are cleared now in this article. Stay tuned for my next guide, Take Care!

Martin Lee

Dorian Winslow is an ASE Master Certified Automotive Service Technician and author of SincereMechanic. Based in Denver, Colorado, Dorian has over 12+ years of experience in the automotive industry. He graduated with honors from Denver Automotive and Diesel College in 2012. Dorian has been developing his writing skills while nurturing a deep passion for cars. His enthusiasm for the automotive world grew even stronger when he became the proud owner of a brand-new Mercedes-Benz in March 2020.